In the bustling corridors of Wall Street, signs are emerging that suggest a bullish trend in the US stock market may be here to stay, potentially extending until 2025. While not overtly striking, these signals carry significant implications for investors looking to navigate the complex landscape of the economy.

The underlying message arises from a noteworthy shift in the performance of risk-based stocks versus defensive stocksThis shift has recently reached unprecedented levels, with non-essential consumer goods outperforming essential goods like never beforeSuch behavior from the market signals a robust appetite for risk among investors, indicating a willingness to bet on the continued spending of consumers on non-essential items. 

At the heart of this analysis is the concept that during times of economic downturn, consumers tend to prioritize their dollars towards essential goods, companies that ensure base needs are met, such as food, hygiene products, and household essentialsHowever, the current trend points towards an optimistic inclination where consumers appear willing to indulge in discretionary spending, primarily within the realm of non-essential goodsThis trend could imply a greater confidence in the economy's capacity to endure potential slowdowns.

Ryan Detrick, chief market strategist at Carson Group, echoes this sentiment, asserting that typically during challenging economic times, defensive stocks would take precedenceInterestingly, the recent statistics reveal that this is not taking place; a positive sign for the bullsNotably, some of the titans in the non-essential sector include Amazon, Tesla, Home Depot, and McDonald’s, whereas giants in the essential goods market comprise Costco, Walmart, and Procter & Gamble, known for their staple products like toilet paper and diapers.

The unprecedented widening gap in performance between these two sectors highlights a bullish sentiment among investors who believe that consumers will continue to expend their income on goods that aren’t necessarily vital but are highly desired

Advertisements

For instance, while essential consumption stocks have typically shown stable growth, the non-essential sector has seen significant movements; year-to-date, non-essential consumer goods have increased nearly 3%, in stark contrast to a 2% decline in essential goods.

Over the past year, essential goods stocks climbed only 7%, while their non-essential counterparts skyrocketed a remarkable 34%. This outperformance can be observed over varying time frames, including three and five years, making it a trend worth notingWhen the S&P 500 index is observed within the same timeframe, it has shown a 2% increase for the year and a favorable rise of 27% over the past year.

Fundamentals have a crucial role to play in these dynamicsArun Sundaram, a senior equity analyst at CFRA Research, points to the thriving labor market as a key factor bolstering non-essential consumer goods stocks, providing consumers with the financial freedom to spend on luxuriesParadoxically, concerns regarding GLP-1 weight-loss drugs have contributed to declines in major essential goods stocks, provoking a debate among investors about the long-term implications of these medications on food and beverage giants dominating the consumer space.

Sundaram emphasizes that investors are increasingly wary of how revolutionary weight-loss treatments like Ozempic will affect the landscape of the food and beverage industry, traditionally resilient sectors that command a large market shareHowever, according to CFRA's chief investment strategist, Sam Stovall, looking beyond the surface of two sectors’ performance disparities, such behavior is quite typical in a bull marketStovall explains that generally, when the non-essential consumer goods sector is on the rise, the S&P 500 tends to follow suit, given the impressive 93% correlation of monthly returns.

In contrast, essential goods have significantly less correlation with the S&P 500, at about 73%. Such data presents a vital context for investors, showcasing bullish tendencies that often accompany rising markets

Advertisements

Stovall underscores this point by detailing how, historically, non-essential consumer goods have shown exceptional performance during market ascents, while essential goods have lagged behind.

Michael Batnick, head of research at Ritholtz Wealth Management, undertook a close examination of equally weighted performances between non-essential and essential consumer goodsHis study sought to elucidate the significant disparity in the weighting of Amazon and Tesla within the non-essential sectorGiven that these two companies command an astounding share of around 40% of this category, their influence inevitably shapes its movements and market performanceBatnick's analysis remains particularly relevant as it investigates the practical implications of this weight imbalance.

Despite the volatility evident in markets, Batnick expresses a sense of reassurance. "I am not concerned by this sell-off; it gives me confidence," he remarked during a recent podcastAdditionally, he characterized the current market conditions as "the most bullish signal globally," noting that such signs are not typically witnessed during bear markets.

Detrick adds that the positive indicators of risk tolerance aren't confined solely to the relative performances of non-essential consumer goodsThis observation echoes sentiments shared by JC Parets, a technical analyst and founder of All Star Charts, who addressed similar perspectives during an interview with "the Compound and Friends." Parets presented long-term ratios illustrating the relative performance between the two sectors, emphasizing the breaking through of key resistance levels observed at market peaks in 2007 and 2021.

Ultimately, this evolving landscape serves as a risk appetite signal, suggesting a prolonged uptrend in the stock marketDetrick notes that the prevailing worry of a potential collapse, often echoed in market chatter, seems overstatedInstead, the right leadership appears to be driving current growth trajectories, suggesting that there may still be room for optimism amid looming uncertainties.

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements